Brandy Broot attends a vinyl listening party at Needle & Groove, the town's beloved vintage record store, when a prized rare record vanishes mid-event. Clues hide in curated playlists, scratched runouts, handwritten liner notes, and competing collector alibis. Brandy decodes musical tastes, delivery receipts, and social debts to find who stole the record and why while Peter steadies her, Maeve keeps the investigation official, and the store's community of listeners reveals loyalty and envy.