Brandy volunteers at Stitch & Sip Quilt Cafe during a weekend quilting retreat when a long-hidden stitched letter is discovered inside a donated quilt, accusing a beloved quilter, Mabel Hart, of stealing a wartime heirloom. The letter triggers old wounds, a theft accusation, and a framed quilter. Brandy unravels threaded clues—needle marks, thread colors, patched receipts, and old meeting notes—while Peter grounds her, Maeve manages the formal investigation, and the cafe community stitches itself toward the truth.